Buying an Annuity for Retirement Makes Sense — Sometimes

Funding a tax-deferred retirement account or plan with another tax-deferred vehicle can be the right choice in some cases, but investors need to understand what they are getting and what they are paying in order to make an informed decision.

Feb 4, 2017 at 4:06PM

The use of annuities inside a qualified retirement plan or IRA has been a controversial practice among financial planners for the past few decades. But new innovations have been added to annuities in recent years, and this has changed the rules of the game in the minds of many planners who once saw annuities as unfit investments for their clients’ retirement assets. There are both advantages and disadvantages to taking this approach, and you need to understand these pros and cons before making a decision to use them.

Why to use an annuity

Annuities are unique retirement savings vehicles that allow investors to save money on a tax-deferred basis even if the annuity contract is not held inside an IRA or other qualified plan. Investors can fund these contracts with either a lump sum or with a series of payments over time. The annuity will then pay the investor a stream of income during retirement. The chief reason why financial planners recommend that their clients invest some portion of their retirement savings in an annuity is that annuities can provide guaranteed lifetime income in the same manner as a corporate or government pension. This can be an important guarantee for clients who live to a ripe old age, as they will be able to continue drawing income from the insurance carrier even after they have gotten back all of their original investment plus the interest or growth in the annuity contract. Variable annuities can also incorporate smart money management strategies such as  dollar-cost averaging  and  portfolio rebalancing.

Another major advantage that many annuities offer is a living benefit rider that guarantees a minimum lifetime payout based upon a promised hypothetical rate of growth. If the hypothetical account balance based on this rate of growth exceeds the actual value of your contract at retirement, then your payout will be calculated based on this higher amount instead of your actual contract value. These riders have made annuities more attractive for many investors and advisors because the hypothetical rates of growth that these riders promise are often higher than the rates offered by other types of guaranteed instruments such as CDs or Treasury securities.

The case against annuities

Despite the advantages of annuities, annuities do have some drawbacks, regardless of whether they are used inside an IRA or qualified plan or not. One of the chief disadvantages is the fees involved. The amount you pay will vary depending upon the type of annuity that you use; there are no fees associated with fixed annuities that simply pay a fixed rate for a set period of time. You will probably pay an annual fee for using an  indexed annuity , which is a special type of fixed annuity that pays interest to the contract based upon the performance of an underlying financial benchmark, such as the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index. When the benchmark rises, interest is credited to the contract, and when the benchmark falls, no interest is credited — but the investor doesn’t lose anything either. Indexed annuities will also charge an additional fee if you opt to use one of the guaranteed income riders that comes with it.

You will pay several types of fees for a  variable annuity , which is a different type of annuity that invests the money that is put into it in a selection of mutual fund subaccounts that will rise and fall with the markets. Variable annuities do not pay a set rate of interest like fixed annuities; the growth in these contracts is based upon the performance of the mutual fund subaccounts. Variable annuity fees include account maintenance fees, fund management fees, and mortality and expense fees. And, as with an indexed annuity, you will also pay an additional charge for any guaranteed living or death benefit riders that you opt to include. And all types of annuities come with back-end surrender charge schedules that will penalize you if you withdraw more than a certain percentage of the contract within the first few years of purchase. Although this schedule eventually falls to zero, it can take several years before it finally disappears.

Furthermore, you cannot roll over your annuity or access the principal in the contract once your guaranteed payout begins; at that point, you have annuitized the contract — that is, you have irrevocably converted the contract into a payout stream that cannot be stopped or modified for any reason. This rule also applies to all types of annuities. For this reason, many investors choose not to annuitize their contracts because they want to retain control over their money when they retire. This means they will not get the income guarantee, but they can still take out a systematic withdrawal for income.

When it comes to using annuities inside your IRA or qualified plan, you’ll need to decide whether you value the advantages that they can provide more than the disadvantages. Despite their fees, indexed annuities may still provide a better rate of return over time than other types of guaranteed investments, so the fees you pay may be worth it. Even fixed annuity contracts typically pay slightly higher yields than CDs or government bonds with very little risk. For more information on whether putting some or all of your retirement money into an annuity makes sense for you, consult your financial advisor.

 

Cussen, Mark.  “Buying an Annuity for Retirement Makes Sense — Sometimes.”   The Motley Fool.  February 4, 2017.  Web.  July 7, 2017.   https://www.fool.com/retirement/2017/02/04/buying-an-annuity-for-retirement-makes-sense-somet.aspx 

This article written by Mark Cussen

Recent Buttonwood Articles


February 21, 2026
Tax season has a way of arriving faster than expected. And for 2026, there’s more worth paying attention to than usual—the IRS has updated key figures for tax year 2025, and enforcement around complex returns has intensified. But before you hand everything off to your CPA, a brief pause to review the right details can make the process smoother—and occasionally surfaces something worth acting on. The questions below are starting points for reflection and conversation, not tax guidance. 1. Did anything significant change last year? Life moves fast, and the tax code tries to keep up. A new job, a growing family, a home purchase, a business change, or even a large one-time expense can shift your tax situation in ways that deserve attention. This is also worth thinking about through the lens of your broader advisor team—changes that affect your investments, estate plan, or business interests often have tax consequences that only surface when everyone is looking at the full picture together. If it felt significant, it’s probably worth mentioning. 2. Have you collected all your income documents? Before anything else, make sure the full picture is on the table. W-2s, 1099s, K-1s, Social Security statements, and brokerage summaries should all be accounted for—and reviewed for accuracy, not just collected. A number that looks wrong is worth questioning before your return is filed. One timing note worth flagging: if you hold interests in partnerships, LLCs, private equity funds, or real estate partnerships, K-1s often don’t arrive until mid-March. If your CPA isn’t expecting them, there’s a real risk of filing prematurely without crucial income information 3. Is your paperwork actually ready to hand off? There’s a difference between having your documents and having them organized. A simple folder—digital or physical—sorted by category saves time, reduces back-and-forth with your CPA, and lowers the chance something gets missed in the shuffle. Five minutes of organizing now can prevent a week of delays later. This matters especially if you work with multiple advisors: your wealth manager, CPA, estate attorney, and business attorney each hold pieces of the puzzle. Information that stays siloed between professionals is one of the most common sources of unnecessary complications at filing time. 4. Are your charitable contributions documented? Good intentions don’t substitute for good records. Whether you gave cash, wrote checks, or donated property, make sure you have acknowledgment letters, receipts, or bank records to back it up. For larger contributions, the bar is higher: cash gifts over $250 require written acknowledgment from the charity, non-cash contributions over $500 require Form 8283, and those over $5,000 typically require a qualified appraisal. If you donated appreciated stock or gave through a donor-advised fund, your CPA will also need cost basis information and confirmation of fair market value on the donation date—details that may require coordination with your investment advisor. Timing matters too—gifts need to have been completed by December 31 to count for the prior tax year. 5. Do you have a clear picture of your investment activity? It’s easy to forget about trades made months ago, but we haven't. Sales, exchanges, dividend reinvestments, and distributions can all carry tax consequences. It’s also worth confirming whether any tax-loss harvesting was done on your behalf during the year—those transactions affect your overall gain and loss picture and your CPA should understand them in context. Similarly, if you exercised stock options, received vested restricted stock, or completed a Roth conversion, those activities need to be clearly communicated. Reviewing your year-end statements before you meet with your CPA helps ensure nothing catches anyone off guard. 6. Did your retirement contributions land where you intended? Confirm that what you planned to contribute actually went in—and in the right accounts. If you came up short on IRA contributions, you may still have time to make it right before the filing deadline. If you own a business or have self-employment income, it’s also worth verifying that any retirement plan contributions made through your business are properly coordinated with your personal return. It’s also worth asking whether your current savings rate still fits your retirement timeline. 7. Are your benefit and healthcare accounts squared away? HSAs, FSAs, and similar accounts have their own rules and reporting requirements that are easy to overlook. An HSA withdrawal used for a non-qualified expense, for instance, can trigger a penalty. Pull together your account statements and any related documents so your CPA has the full picture. If you own a business, it’s also worth confirming that health insurance premiums paid through your company are being handled correctly on both your business and personal returns—this is an area where coordination between your bookkeeper and CPA matters more than people expect. 8. What do you want to be more intentional about this year? Tax season is one of the few times most people take a genuine look at their finances. Use that momentum. Beyond filing, consider asking your CPA what your estimated tax payments should look like for 2026, whether any positions on this return carry higher audit risk, and what planning opportunities exist based on what they’re seeing in your return. The IRS has meaningfully intensified enforcement around high-income filers in recent years—particularly around partnership interests, digital asset transactions, and international holdings—so this isn’t a moment to treat compliance as a formality. Whether it’s adjusting your withholding, revisiting your giving strategy, or thinking through a major financial decision ahead, the earlier a conversation starts, the more options you typically have. A Note on 2025 Figures The IRS adjusted several key thresholds for tax year 2025. The standard deduction increased to $15,750 for single filers and $31,500 for married filing jointly, with an additional enhanced deduction of up to $6,000 per qualifying individual age 65 or older ($12,000 for married couples where both spouses qualify). Notably, legislation temporarily increased the cap on state and local tax (SALT) deductions to up to $40,000 for tax years 2025 through 2029 for certain taxpayers who itemize. This expanded cap is subject to income‑based limitations and may phase down for higher‑income filers, meaning the benefit varies significantly based on overall income and deduction profile. As always, whether itemizing or taking the standard deduction makes sense depends on your specific situation and should be reviewed with your CPA. Estate and gift tax exemptions also saw inflationary adjustments for 2025, which may be relevant if wealth‑transfer planning was part of your year. How we can help? We work alongside your CPA—not in place of them. Our role is to help you stay organized, think through priorities, and make sure your financial decisions are working together toward a bigger goal. In our experience, the families who navigate tax season most efficiently are those who proactively connect the pieces across their professional team, rather than assuming the information flows automatically. If it would be helpful to talk through what’s on your plate before you sit down with your tax advisor, we’re glad to do that. Thank you for your continued trust and for allowing us to provide solutions-not just plans. This information is provided for general educational purposes only and should not be considered tax advice. Please consult your tax professional regarding your specific situation
Investmen
By Dale Raimann January 7, 2026
As we closed out 2025, our Investment Policy Committee (IPC) continued its work to refine strategies that balance risk, liquidity, and long-term growth. In our previous update , we shared how the inflation shock of 2022 reshaped our approach to fixed income and led to a more nimble, systematic positioning of bond assets. That proactive discipline remains a cornerstone of our investment process. As we wrapped up 2025, our Investment Policy Committee (IPC) continues efforts to refine strategies that balance risk, liquidity, and long-term growth. With the Fed reducing overnight lending rates for the third time, recent IPC discussions have turned to another critical focus area: cash management. Why Cash Strategy Matters Now With interest rates still elevated and market uncertainty persisting, many investors hold larger-than-usual cash positions. While cash provides stability, it also introduces opportunity cost if left idle. One of our IPC objectives is to ensure that excess cash works harder for you, without compromising liquidity for emergencies or near-term cash needs. Refining Our Cash Allocation Policy For our clients with larger cash needs (generally more than 5% or $50k of liquid assets in cash or money market funds), we are shifting to a proactive T-Bill management strategy, or other suitable investments based on goals and circumstances. For our clients holding less than $50k in cash or money market, we have retained money market for liquidity, but we have made a switch to the default money market fund we are using. Risk and Tax Aware Money Market Selection While yields are similar across money markets today, the underlying investments in each money market fund vary quite a bit. For example, Schwab Prime Money Market (ticker SWVXX) offers a slightly higher yield but invests in asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP), introducing a modest credit risk. In contrast, Schwab Government Money Market (ticker SNVXX), invests primarily in U.S. Treasuries and government-backed securities, making it virtually risk-free and often state income tax-advantaged. With lower risk and only about 10/100’s of 1% yield difference, our IPC has proactively transitioned clients from SWVXX to SNVXX, to prioritize safety and tax efficiency over a marginal yield difference. Connecting Back to Our Broader Strategy These cash management refinements build on the fixed income strategy we recently outlined. By reducing exposure to inflation-sensitive bonds and implementing a more systematic approach, we are positioning portfolios to be more resilient across potentially weaker or higher-rate environments. Optimizing cash allocations and minimizing credit risk within money markets reinforces the same core principle—protecting downside risk while prudently capturing incremental return opportunities. Looking Ahead As we enter 2026, our investment approach remains focused and disciplined. We continue to prioritize liquidity for cash needs, thoughtful risk management, and systematic investment strategies designed to adapt to evolving market and economic conditions. This proactive framework supports long-term portfolio resilience while remaining aligned with your financial objectives. If you have questions about how these updates may impact your investments, cash management, or overall financial plan, we encourage you to connect with your financial advisor at Buttonwood. Our team is committed to delivering personalized wealth management and asset allocation strategies—regardless of market or economic uncertainty. Thank you for your continued trust and for allowing us to coordinate your asset management as part of our Family CFO services.
How to Talk About Money with Family Over the Holidays
December 23, 2025
How to Talk About Money with Family Over the Holidays. Whether your family is just beginning to plan or has been navigating financial decisions across generations
December 12, 2025
As year-end approaches, many clients focus on charitable giving—supporting causes they care about while optimizing their tax strategy. This year carries added urgency: the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) will significantly change charitable giving rules in 2026.
Buttonwood Investment Policy Committee Update
By Jon McGraw November 24, 2025
Maintain diversification as one of our risk management tools, focusing on our high-conviction ideas that tie with where we feel we are in the economic cycle.
Buttonwood Investment Policy Committee Update
By Kyle Hogan September 26, 2025
Our Investment Policy Committee (IPC) remains focused on balancing opportunity with discipline as markets continue to react to shifting economic and geopolitical dynamics. Following a volatile start to the year, recent developments have created a more constructive environment for risk assets, though caution remains war

Are you ready to explore the benefits of your very own Family CFO?

LET'S TALK

Buttonwood Services


About Buttonwood Financial Group